So far I've only tried one Indian Tabac. It's a tick below the Rocky Patels I've tried but you can tell that the same care went into them. They are a good low-priced smoke.

I tried the Torano Virtuoso last night and the Torano Signature tonight. Both are good smokes, but like you I prefer the Exodus 1959. Toranos never disappoint. I would have to say so far that among the smokes I can get regularly, the Toranos and Patels are my favorites. I like the Graycliff a lot, but at $25-30 a stick I can't buy many of them.